Home

 

 
Taxonomy & Evolution
 
Section 1 - Taxonomy
Section 2 - Butterfly Families and subfamilies
Section 3 - What is a species / subspecies ?
Section 4 - Evolution and Speciation
Section 5 - Lepidoptera and the Evolutionary table
 
What is a species ?

Morphological species

In past times any two butterflies that looked identical in structure and markings were assumed to be the same species, and named accordingly. However we now know that there are many species involved in "mimicry rings" whereby several different species can produce visually identical adults.
 
Conversely we also know that it is quite common for a single species to produce several different forms or morphs, which previously might have been classified as different species.
 
A good example of this phenomenon is the Mocker Swallowtail Papilio dardanus - the male is cream in colour, and possesses tails on the hindwings, but the female has an entirely different wing shape, does not possess tails, and produces several forms, each differing in colour and pattern, but all mimicking various toxic species from the Danaine genera Danaus and Amauris, and the Acraeine genus Bematistes.
 
Another problem with morphological species is that apparently identical adult butterflies can have early stages ( eggs, caterpillars, chrysalises ) that differ in structure. Scientists therefore began wherever possible to examine the full lifecycle rather than just the adult butterflies, and as a result several new species were discovered, e.g. the apparently identical Clouded Yellows Colias alfacariensis and C. hyale were thought to be the same species until Berger discovered distinct differences in the larvae and pupae.
 
Closely related morphological species are often so similar that it is not possible from visual examination to determine whether they represent varieties / subspecies of one butterfly, or whether they are biologically different ( but visually identical ) species.

Biological species

These are defined as creatures which breed with other biologically identical creatures, and produce fertile offspring. To prevent interbreeding, each species of butterfly and moth has uniquely shaped genitalia - the male "key" only fitting the correct female "lock".

Hybrids - Despite Nature's mechanisms for the prevention of interbreeding, hybridisation between species does occasionally occur, but hybrids are by definition infertile, so they cannot pass on their characteristics to another generation.

Often the male and female of a particular butterfly are totally different in appearance, and may not initially be recognised as belonging to the same taxon. By examining the "lock and key" genitalia, taxonomists have often discovered that 2 insects previously classified under entirely different genera are actually the same biological species !

Cladistics

 

Cladistics is a system whereby comparative data is analysed quantitatively, and used to construct cladograms. These represent the evolutionary tree of life, and are used to illustrate the assumed phylogenetic relations and evolutionary history of groups of organisms.
 
In simple terms, if two sample specimens were analysed and found to share only a low number of common characteristics, this would imply that they were only distantly related, i.e. that they split from their common ancestor a very long time ago. They would therefore be placed in separate families. At the other extreme, if the number of shared characteristics was extremely high, it would imply that the specimens were very closely related, having split from a common ancestor relatively recently. Hence they would be placed in the same family, and possibly in the same genus.
 
For both sample insects to be recognised as belonging to the same species, ALL characteristics ( of the same sex ) would of course be identical.
 
The usual method favoured by entomologists involves microscopic examination and measurement of the constituent parts of the genitalia of both sexes. Dozens, or sometimes hundreds of these characteristics need to be analysed and quantified to enable the relationships between species to be established.
 
Genitalia analysis is the primary tool used in determining relationships and "evolutionary trees", but only tells part of the story. Other methods of determination include study of wing-scale structure, leg structure, egg, caterpillar and chrysalis morphology, larval host-plant usage, behavioural analysis and DNA sequencing.

What is a "subspecies" ?

Butterflies can loosely be divided into 3 camps regarding genetic interchange :
 
The first group comprises species such as the Painted Lady Vanessa cardui, the Small White Pieris rapae and the Pea Blue / Long-tailed Blue Lampides boeticus which are migratory in behaviour and cosmopolitan in distribution. Their nomadic nature brings them into fairly regular contact with distant "cousins" of their own species, so genetic interchange occurs frequently. A Painted Lady in Australia therefore is genetically almost identical to a Painted Lady in Europe, Africa, Asia or North America. Accordingly all races are designated as Vanessa cardui, and there are no recognised subspecies.
 
The second group comprises of endemics - species which are native to and confined to a limited area such as a particular island or mountain range. Examples include Calisto confusa which is found only in Haiti; Baronia brevicornis, found only in deciduous scrub forests of s.w. Mexico; Eresia sticta which is restricted to Costa Rica; and Henotesia comorensis - a butterfly confined to the Comoro Islands north-west of Madagascar. By definition endemics have no other races of their own species with which they can interbreed, so there are no subspecies.
 
The vast majority of butterfly species fall into the third group, which comprises those species which are quite widespread in distribution, but whose populations, due to changes in climate or vegetation have become isolated from each other for hundreds or thousands of years. Such populations have no opportunity to interbreed, so genetic interchange is virtually non-existent, and accordingly each isolated population develops its own characteristics. The Scottish race of the Large Heath e.g. lacks ocelli on the wings and is known as Coenonympha tullia scotica, while the larger and much darker race from Bosnia-Herzegovina, with very prominent ocelli, is recognised as a different subspecies Coenonympha tullia lorkovici.
 
The subspecies phenomenon is particularly prevalent in South America, where areas of rainforest have during several periods of the Earth's climatic history become isolated as a result of glaciation or desertification. The result of this long term separation of populations is particularly noticeable in the genus Heliconius - in the case of the Common Longwing Heliconius erato for example there are no less than 29 recognised subspecies, each with a different pattern.
 
If populations have been isolated for several millennia the differences between them can be very pronounced - patterns, colours, size, and even the shape of the wings can be different, particularly if the races evolve in different habitats and climates.
 
Sometimes, due to the periodic contraction and expansion of forested areas, subspecies which have been isolated for many thousands of years can be reunited, thus it is possible, and in fact not uncommon, to find more than one subspecies occurring in the same area of forest.
 
By definition, all subspecies of any given species are physically capable of interbreeding and can produce fertile offspring. Although such interbreeding may not necessarily occur naturally, it can be induced in captivity.
 
Some evolutionists argue that if a subspecies becomes isolated for a long enough period of time, it will ultimately evolve structural differences ( e.g. in the genitalia ) that make it physically impossible for it to interbreed with other subspecies, and that if and when this occurs the 2 forms have become sufficiently different for them to be reclassified as separate species, i.e. the evolution of a new species will have occurred.
 
Others argue that DNA analysis of various subspecies on remote islands in Melanesia indicates that when populations become isolated, inbreeding and genetic entropy occurs, which is contradictory to most theories of evolution, which state that as species evolve they advance - thereby increasing rather than decreasing the number of chemical base pairs in their genome.
 
 
 
 
 

NEXT >>

 

 

About me

Contact me

Butterfly study holidays

Trip reports

Butterfly diary - latest sightings

Frequently asked questions

Test your knowledge

Strange but true !

Where to find butterflies

Taxonomy & Evolution

Anatomy

Lifecycle

Enemies of butterflies

Ecology

Survival strategies

Migration / dispersal

Habitats - UK

Habitats - Tropical rainforests

Butterfly world census

Books

Butterfly photography

Butterflies of the British Isles

Butterflies of Europe

Butterflies of Amazon & Andes

Butterflies of North America

Butterflies of Africa

Butterflies of India & Nepal

Butterflies of Malaysia

Butterflies of Papua New Guinea

Butterflies of Australia

Butterflies of New Zealand

Moths - marvels of nature

Moths - Britain & Europe

Moths - Amazon & Andes

Caterpillars - the infinite variety

Insects of Amazonia

Species index

Subject index

Glossary

Links

Code of practice

Copyright - text & images

Feedback

Website status

 

All photographs, artwork, text & website design are the property of Adrian Hoskins ( unless otherwise stated ) and are protected by Copyright. Photographs or text on this website must not be reproduced in part or in whole or published elsewhere without prior written consent of Adrian Hoskins / learnaboutbutterflies.com

Site hosted by Just Host